The poll is over and MYST is the chosen game for October, a game that I will LP (maybe Live) and make sure to finish. I have not played MYST in ages (ha-ha) and I intend to fully play the game rather than simply doing the quick "I know how to finish this game"-route.
But which version? The cleaned-up original in MYST: Masterpiece Edition or the updated 3D version of RealMYST? Your choice!